top of page

Lunch Time Favorites
Available Monday-Friday 11:00 am to 4:00 pm

Scotch Eggs - Copy
Fish Fry - Copy
French Onion Soup 6
Hero Sandwich
Burger 5
Salmon Platter
French Onion Soup
CHEESE STEAK 5 - Copy (2)
Side Salad
Fish Fry 2

 ~ Appetizers & Fun Fare ~ 


Clare’s Calamari.... $12.99

Hand Breaded, Deep Fried Baby Calamari

with Garlic Aioli…  “A Touch of Galway Bay”!


Corned Beef Shalaylee... $14.99

Egg Rolls filled with Corned Beef, Cabbage, & Swiss Cheese placed on a bed of Greens Drizzled with Sesame Vinaigrette Dressing... Served with Thousand Island Dressing 


Irish Potato Skins.... $14.99

Deep Fried Potato Skins filled with Cheese, Bacon Bits, Diced Tomato & Scallions served

with Homemade Salsa & Sour Cream

Irish Smoked Salmon.... $14.99

Irish Smoked Salmon, Dill Sauce, Cream Cheese, Red Onions, Capers & Chopped Egg… Served on Toasted Guinness Crostini on a Bed of Greens


Leprechaun “Pot-O’-Gold.... $14.99

Deep-Fried Onion Rings, Cheese Curds, Jalapeno Poppers, Fried Pickles, & Shalaylee's... Served with Ranch or Thousand Island Dressing


Hot Soft Pretzels w/ Cheese Dip... $9.99 

Delicious Hot, Soft Pretzels Served with your Choice of Our Own Special Four Cheese Dip, Jalapeno Cheese Sauce, Honey Mustard, or Dijon Mustard

Both Cheese Dips... $1.00 Extra 

~ Entrée Salads ~

Dressings… Ranch, Low-Fat Ranch, French, Bleu Cheese, Thousand Island, Caesar, Honey Mustard,

Parmesan Peppercorn, Fat-Free Sesame Vinaigrette, Raspberry Viaigrette

(Add Toasted Garlic Bread… $2.50)



Erin’s Caesar Salad... $12.99

Fresh Romaine Lettuce tossed in Caesar Dressing with Cherry Tomatoes, Fresh Parmesan Cheese & Herb Croutons

With Grilled Chicken, Steak, Shrimp or Deep-  Fried Calamari... Add 6.99

Beetroot & Bleu Cheese Salad... $13.99

Mixed Greens, Apples, Toasted Walnuts,           Beets & Bleu Cheese…Served with Choice of Dressing


Crispy Chicken Salad... $16.99

Mixed Greens, Hand Breaded Fried Chicken Tenders, Mandarin Oranges & Diced Tomatoes…Served with Choice of Dressing

Shelby’s Healthy Choice... $16.99

Spinach, Grilled Chicken, Toasted Walnuts,  Apple Slices & Bleu Cheese Crumbles Served with Raspberry Vinaigrette Dressing on the Side


Blackened Mahi Mahi Salad... $17.99

Mixed Greens, Apples, Blackened Mahi Mahi, Pineapple, Cucumber, Chopped Red Onions, & Cherry Tomatoes… Served with Choice of Dressing

Colleen’s Cobb Salad... $17.99

Mixed Greens, Chicken, Bacon, Avocado, Cherry   Tomatoes, Egg, Beets & Bleu Cheese… Served  

with Choice of Dressing


~ Erin's Classic Sandwiches ~

Served with Pickle Spear   

Add Coleslaw $1.99   Add Pub Fries, Pub Chips, Thin Cut or Sweet Potato Fries $2.99


Erin’s Corned Beef Sandwich... $12.99

Thinly Sliced Homemade Corned Beef, Fresh Sauerkraut & Melted Swiss Cheese with Our Signature Mary Rose Sauce… Served on Triple Deck Marble Rye Bread


Rachel’s Choice Sandwich...$11.99

Turkey, Sauerkraut, Swiss Cheese & 1000 Island Dressing on Grilled Marble Rye Bread... (May Substitute Coleslaw for Sauerkraut)



Walnut Veggie Burger... $11.99

A Wisconsin Made Vegetarian Alternative… Served on a Hamburger Bun



O' Shea's Philly Cheese Steak... $15.99

Shaved Prime Rib, Sautéed Onions, Peppers & Mushrooms topped with Melted Swiss Cheese… Served with Jalapeño Cheese Sauce or Garlic Aioli on Erin’s Gaelic Hoagie


Hearty Blarney Beef Burger... $11.99

Certified 8 oz Angus Beef Paddy Grilled with a Touch of Butter & Our Own Seasoning

Add Lettuce Tomato & Red Onion Upon Request      

      With... Cheese...Add 1.00   Mushrooms... Add .50   

                 Bacon….Add 3.00   Bleu Cheese….Add 1.50 

                 Bratwurst... Add 1.75   Sauerkraut… Add 1.00 

Fried Egg… Add 1.50

Half Hearty Beef Burger.. $9.99

Certified Quarter Pound Angus Beef Paddy Grilled with a Touch of Butter & Our Own Seasoning

Add Lettuce Tomato & Red Onion Upon Request 

Bucky’s Best Wurst… $12.99

Grilled Johnsonville Bratwursts Split & Served Open, Smothered with Swiss Cheese, Sauerkraut & Onions… Served on a Hearty Burger Bun

Galway Bay Fish Sandwich... $11.99

8 oz. Lightly Hand Breaded Cod Filet… Served with Lettuce, Tomato, Onion & Homemade Tarter Sauce on Erin’s Gaelic Hoagie… Add Cheese upon Request $1.00 

Mediterranean Chicken... $13.99

Grilled Chicken Breast with Onions, Peppers, & Sun Dried Tomato Vinaigrette… Served on Erin’s Gaelic Hoagie 


Tuna Salad Sandwich... $9.99

Erin’s Own Special Tuna Blend with Diced Celery & Red Onion… Served on Berry Wheat Bread with Lettuce & Tomato


Chicken Salad Sandwich ... $9.99

Erin’s Own Special Chicken Blend with Diced  Celery & Red Onion…Served on Berry Wheat Bread with Lettuce & Tomato

TBLT... $9.99

A Generous Portion of Turkey, Bacon, Lettuce, & Tomato… Served on Berry Wheat Toast 

Paddy’s Pulled Pork... $10.99

Pit Smoked Pulled Pork made with Erin’s Whiskey BBQ Sauce Served on Erin’s Gaelic Hoagie


O’ Reilly's Rueben... $12.99

Corned Beef, Sauerkraut, Swiss Cheese & 1000 Island Dressing on Grilled Marble Rye Bread

Hogan’s Hero... $10.99

Turkey, Ham, Bacon, Tomato, Onion, Lettuce, Cheddar & Swiss Cheese with Mayo on Erin’s Gaelic Hoagie


~ That's A Wrap ~
Served with Pickle Spear
   Add Coleslaw $1.9
9   Add Pub Fries, Pub Chips, Thin Cut or Sweet Potato Fries $2.99  

Smoked Salmon Wrap... $12.99 

Cold Smoked Salmon, Mixed Greens, Cream Cheese, Onion,  Capers & Chopped

Egg with a Creamy Dill Sauce


Chicken Caesar Wrap... $10.99

Grilled Chicken Breast, Romaine Lettuce, Caesar Dressing, Shredded Parmesan


Chicken Salad Wrap... $10.99

Erin’s Own Chicken Blend with Celery & Onion with Romaine Lettuce & Diced Tomato


Chicken Burrito Wrap... $10.99

Grilled Chicken Breast, Lettuce, Shredded Cheddar Cheese, Corn, Diced Tomatoes, Black Bean Salsa... Served Warm with Sour Cream


T.B.L.T. Wrap... $10.99

Turkey, Bacon, Romaine Lettuce, Diced Tomato

& Mayo

Club Wrap... $11.99

Turkey, Ham, Swiss & Cheddar Cheese, Mayo, Bacon, Mixed Greens, Diced Tomato, Onion

Dijon Chicken Wrap... $10.99

Hand Breaded Chicken Tenders with Lettuce, Tomato, Bacon, & Dijon Honey Mustard


Tuna Salad Wrap... $10.99

Erin’s Own Tuna Blend with Diced Sweet Pickles, Celery & Onion with Romaine Lettuce & Diced Tomato


O'Reilly's Reuben Wrap... $12.99

Corned Beef, Sauerkraut, Swiss Cheese & 1000 Island Dressing


~ Irish Specialties ~

Shepherd’s Pie... $17.99

Erin’s Own Special Recipe of Ground Black Angus Beef & Lamb in a Savory Gravy with Traditional Vegetables topped with Colcannon, Baked until Golden Brown


Daily News Fish & Chips... $17.99

From the Cold Atlantic, Two 4 oz Filets of Hand-Breaded Cod… Served with Tarter Sauce, Lemon Wedge & Coleslaw


O’ Dana’s Bangers & Mash... $16.99

Three Traditional Fried Bangers served around Colcannon, Cooked Apples & Onions


Cottage Pie... $17.99

Chicken Stew made with Carrots, Peas, Onions, & Celery surrounding a hearty helping of Colcannon

Guinness Stew... $16.99

Homemade Beef Stew with a Savory Guinness Sauce… Topped with a Puff Pastry 


Corned Beef & Cabbage... $17.99

Tender Corned Beef & Cabbage with Red Potatoes & Assorted Vegetables in a Natural Beef Broth


Irish Breakfast... $16.99

Start your day the Irish way!  2 Eggs, 1 Banger Sausage, 2 Pieces Rasher Bacon, Grilled Tomato & Mushrooms…  Served with Berry Wheat Toast & Choice of Potato 


Murphy's Irish Stew... $16.99

Erin's Snug's Own Special Recipe is Brewed In-House with Seven Vegetables and Tender Beef Tips topped with a Puff Pastry 


~ Choosing Sides ~

Erin’s Colcannon... $3.99

A Blend of Homemade Mashed Potatoes & Cabbage


Fully Loaded Colcannon... $5.99

Mashed Potatoes, Cabbage, Diced Scallions (Green Onions), Crushed Bacon, Melted Cheddar Cheese & Sour Cream 


Steamed Seasonal Vegetables... $4.99


Pub Fries... $3.99

Sweet Potato Fries... $3.99

McConnell's Thin Cut Fries... $3.99


Baked Potato... $3.99



Wisconsin Fried Cheese Curds... $12.99

Our own Hand Breaded Fried Cheddar Cheese Curds, all Fresh, Never Frozen...  Served with Choice of Ranch Dressing or Marinara Sauce... Both Dressings $1 Extra 



Brew City Onion Rings... $9.99

Sweet Onions Deep Fried Golden Brown

Fried Hamburger Dill Pickles... 8.99

Golden Deep Fried Hamburger Dill Pickles… Served with Choice of Ranch, Jalapeno Ranch, Bleu Cheese OR Thousand Island Dressing… Extra Dressings $1.00 Each


Side Salad... $5.99

Mixed Greens, Cherry Tomatoes, Croutons, Cucumbers & Onions… Served with Choice of Dressing



Mc Gregor's Mac & Cheese... $16.99

Our Own Mac & Four Cheese Blend, Diced Tomato, Crushed Bacon & Jalapeno Peppers sprinkled with Parmesan Cheese & Toasted Bread Crumbs… Served with Toasted Garlic Bread

With Grilled Chicken...19.99 



Wisconsin Style Chili

Cup. . . . $5.99 . . . . Bowl . . . . $7.99

Loaded with Fresh Ground Beef, Bacon, Tomatoes, Green Peppers, Onions & Kidney Beans…Topped with Shredded Wisconsin Cheddar Cheese, Diced Green Onions & Sour Cream




French Onion Soup

Bowl... $7.99

Auntie Joan’s Homemade French Onion Soup… Topped with Croutons, Melted Swiss Cheese & Deep-Fried Onion Straws



Soup O' the Day

Cup... $4.99  Bowl... $5.99

(Ask Your Server for Today's Special)

Nicole Slaw... $2.99


~ Children's Menu ~

Ask Our Hostess Or Your Server for Our Children’s Activities Menu


~ Just Desserts ~

Each Dessert is Created Especially for You!

French Toast Sundae... $9.99

This Signature Dessert consists of a Cinnamon French Toast Base smothered in Warm Maple Syrup, then topped with Vanilla Ice Cream, Whipped Cream, Candied Walnuts & a Cherry… Surrounded by Chocolate Syrup Swirls


Pecan Turtle Cheese Cake... $6.99

This Delight is filled with Pecans, Caramel & Rich Chocolate


Old Fashion Bread Pudding... $9.99

English Style Bread Pudding loaded with Raisins and a Touch of Cinnamon then topped with Sweet Brandy Sauce 

Guinness Chocolate Cake... $9.99

This Chocolate Masterpiece is Our Customer’s Favorite… Five Layers of Chocolate Cake with a Rich Ganache Filling Between each layer, then iced with Cream Cheese Frosting


Bailey's Irish  Cheesecake... $6.99

Rich Creamy Cheesecake with a Hint of Irish

Crème... Topped with Milk Chocolate Mousse


Sweet Soft Pretzels... $9.99

Fried Soft Pretzels dusted with Powdered Sugar & Cinnamon...Served with Choice of Maple Syrup or Caramel Syrup


We Hope You Enjoy Your Visit!

bottom of page